October 15, 2015

Why are we trying to make feminism seem so complicated?

PARIS, FRANCE - JULY 07:  Jennifer Lawrence and Emma Watson attend the Christian Dior show as part of Paris Fashion Week - Haute Couture Fall/Winter 2014-2015 at Muse Rodin on July 7, 2014 in Paris, France.  (Photo by Rindoff/Dufour/French Select/Getty Images)

This is a guest post by Sirena Bergman, a journalist and editor based in London, she tweets @sirenabergman and blogs at sirenabergman.com.

Being a feminist means believing in equality. It’s that straightforward. If you believe that women are just as able, deserving and entitled to be heard as men, you are a feminist. If you have ever met a person with a vagina, you have no excuse to not be a feminist. If you are a human inhabiting this planet, you have to be a feminist. This is because equality amongst people of all genders, race, nationality and social backgrounds is crucial to making the world a better place for us all.

Being a feminist doesn’t mean you have to represent every woman, or address every single possible aspect of the struggle every time you open your mouth.

Emma Watson decided to use her celebrity and social standing to push for men to get involved in feminism by giving a legendary speech at the UN headquarters. Her words would probably have faded into obscurity if they’d been spoken by someone non-headline-worthy, but she paved the way for both men and women to stand up and speak for the importance of equal rights. Well apparently that’s just not good enough.

In a Twitter Q&A she was asked whether she is a “white feminist”. Without going into a pedantic diatribe about the semantic flaws in this phrase, it’s basically the new version of “check your privilege”, which means that you should strive to be inclusive with your arguments, and recognise the fact that there are people who are at a disadvantage in comparison to your position. That sounds kind of like what she did when she visited Zambia and Bangladesh to promote education for girls, or travelled to Uruguay to discuss female participation in politics. That doesn’t strike me as someone who can’t see beyond her own luck in life.

You know who should be told to check their privilege? The bunch of middle-class white men we voted in, who are penalising women for having more children than they’ve deemed acceptable (intentionally or otherwise), who decided childcare and streetlights aren’t a big deal, and who refuse to properly fund organisations that are pushing for equality.

Emma Watson isn’t trying to speak for people whose position she’s not in. She acknowledged that their situation is important but focussed on the issues she feels attached to. Yet much like Lena Dunham, Caitlin Moran, Amy Schumer and countless others before them, all people can home in on is what she didn’t say. Even when she eloquently and patiently defended herself, she was still subject to unsubstantiated claims of racial unawareness. Concluding her response on Twitter, she said: “I want to hear as many voices as possible, I want to hear other people’s stories. This is a universal and global movement”.

Feminism isn’t a fight against each other. It’s not about silencing other feminists because they don’t look like you. Women gaining a platform to speak about the issues affecting them will pave the way for the rest of us to tell our stories; women rising to the top will yank the rest of us up with them. Bickering about a turn of phrase or a lack of inclusivity is legitimising arguments that feminism is difficult, complicated or for the educated few.

I’m white too, but Emma Watson doesn’t represent me. She’s from an incredibly privileged background, was privately educated, conforms to socially established beauty standards (she’s playing Belle, for God’s sake) and is worth an estimated $60 million. But it’s because of her privilege that she has the platform that she does and I just wish more women in her position would speak up for those of us they can’t reach an audience as easily. Perhaps more women would speak out if we didn’t make it our primary principle to persecute them for not being every single thing to every single person with a Twitter account.

*I am interested in publishing a wide range of opinions and voices. If you are interesting in contributing a guest post, email me at girllostinthecityblog@gmail.com.*

4 Responses

  1. L.B. says:

    “If you believe that women are just as able, deserving and entitled to be heard as men, you are a feminist. ”

    It may also mean that you simply believe that people are people.

  2. Alice beatty says:

    Thank the Lord that someone has spoken on this!!! I can’t believe how complicated the Internet makes feminism when it’s the simplist idea ever! And the term white feminism just infuriates me so much! Great post I’d love to get involved some way xx

  3. Mark says:

    I’m a man who has become very worried about everything I do as being sexist and misogynistic. From what I’ve read holding a door open is sexist as it means I’m assuming she’s weaker than me but that’s not my intention, but not holding a door open is rude and discrimination or something as I’ve placed my importance over women’s. It’s like if I and a woman are hitting it off I’m scared to kiss her in case she doesn’t want it and screams I’m assaulting her and if a woman is drunk and starts shoving me I can’t defend myself as I’d be victim shaker for hitting a woman. It’s just all sondamn complicated and worrisome.

    (If some thinking trolling I’m not I’m genuinely feeling that I can do nothing right and no matter what I’d be in the wrong)

  4. Lisa says:

    Emma Watson said something in her “He for she” speech which I really liked, which was when she pointed out that the word Feminism is not important, it’s fighting for Equality that is, and I agree with this. I didn’t like everything she said in that speech, but I agreed with that point. Although I don’t identify as a Feminist or Humanist. I identify as an Egalitarian. That way nobody is left out. It is all very well for people to say that Feminists don’t leave out women who lack certain privileges, but much of my experience meeting people who say they are Feminists has proven this not to be the case.

Leave a Reply

My New Book

The world of work is changing - so how do you keep up?
You have the ability to make money on our own terms, when and where you want - but where do you start?

If you've been itching to convert your craft into a career, or your side-hustle into a start up, then The Multi-Hyphen Method is for you.